OscarCentral.com


Charting the Oscar Winner Predictors

Below you will find what is believed to be an accurate reading of the final Oscar winner predictions of many print and online Oscar predictors. Though we've tried to remain as accurate as possible, the chart may very well contain errors. Please send comments, corrections, updates and additions to us via our comment form.


Last Updated March 6, 2006 @ 12:48am (PT)

Source
All
Top 21
Top 8
 
Picture
Actor
Actress
S. Actor
S. Actress
Orig. Screenpl.
Adapt. Screenpl.
Director
Anim. Feat.
Foreign
Cinematog.
Art Dir.
Vis. Effects
Costume
Make-Up
Editing
Score
Song
Sound
Sound Edit.
Doc. Short
Doc. Feature
Anim. Short
Live Action Short
THE WINNERS 
       
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
Kong
Triumph
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
 
Academy Tracker (Variety)
79% (19/24)
% (18/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Farm
Adam Lucyk (Oscar Beachhouse)
75% (18/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Adams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
America's Line
83% (10/12)
83% (10/12)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
-
-
-
-
-
-
Brokeback
Transamerica
-
-
-
-
-
-
Andy Scott (Everything Oscar)
84% (16/19)
84% (16/19)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Walk
Kong
 -
 -
-
-
Anne Thompson (N.Y. Magazine)
67% (16/24)
86% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Kong
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
9
Our Time
Carla Meyer (Sacramento Bee)
80% (8/10)
80% (8/10)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Penguins
-
-
Christy Lemire (AP)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Williams
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Cifra (Cifra2's Mania)
70% (7/10)
70% (7/10)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Williams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Murderball
-
-
Claudia Pulg (USA Today)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Daniel Kenealy (Oscar Watch)
71% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Daniel Stasiewski (Film Chair)
67% (16/24)
71% (15/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Ledger
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Munich
Brokeback
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Darren Keeny (Movie Experience)
77% (10/13)
77% (10/13)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Penguins
-
-
Dave (Oscar Frenzy)
76% (16/21)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Dave Germaine (AP)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Huffman
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Dave Karger (EW)
79% (11/14)
79% (11/14)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Penguins
-
-
David Ansen (Newsweek)
81% (17/21)
81% (17/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Walk
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
David Carr (New York Times)
75% (18/24)
81% (17/21)
100% (8/8)
 
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Enron
9
Shooter
David Fear (MSN)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
David Poland (Movie City News)
58% (14/24)
62% (13/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Star Wars
-
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
Kong
Mushroom
Penguins
Jasper
Shooter
David Silverberg (DigitalJournal.com)
80% (4/5)
80% (4/5)
67% (4/6)
 
-
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Drewbacca (Movie Patron)
38% (8/21)
38% (8/21)
38% (3/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
McDormand
Good
Constant
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Pride
Cinderella
Munich
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
War
-
Penguins
-
-
Edward Douglas (ComingSoon.com)
63% (15/24)
71% (15/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Sophie
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Hustle
War
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Edward Havens (Film Jerk)
50% (5/10)
50% (5/10)
63% (5/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Knightley
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
-
Sophie
Good
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Ed Gonzalez & Eric Henderson (Slant)
90% (9/10)
90% (9/10)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Penguins
-
-
Emmanuel Levy (EmmanuelLevy.com)
75% (18/24)
81% (18/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Constant
Memoirs
Hustle
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
Badgered
Our Time
E!
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Adams
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Source
All
Top 21
Top 8
 
Picture
Actor
Actress
S. Actor
S. Actress
Orig. Screenpl.
Adapt. Screenpl.
Director
Anim. Feat.
Foreign
Cinematog.
Art Dir.
Vis. Effects
Costume
Make-Up
Editing
Score
Song
Sound
Sound Edit.
Doc. Short
Doc. Feature
Anim. Short
Live Action Short
Entertainment Weekly
67% (16/24)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
Kong
Death
Penguins
9
Runaway
Eugene Hernandez (indieWIRE)
71% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Murderball
One
Shooter
Garret (Oscar Predictions)
58% (14/24)
67% (14/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
War
Death
Penguins
Badgered
Runaway
Gene Seymour (Newsday)
71% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Memoirs
Memoirs
Narnia
Memoirs
Narnia
Munich
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
9
Shooter
HSX (Awards Options)
88% (7/8)
88% (7/8)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Iain Pardoe (2005 Predictions)
75% (3/4)
75% (3/4)
75% (3/4)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
-
-
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Jack Matthews (New York Daily News)
67% (10/15)
67% (8/12)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
-
Moon
Shooter
Jacob Hall (Independent Critics)
33% (8/24)
38% (8/21)
38% (3/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Huffman
Giamatti
Adams
Crash
Brokeback
Spielberg
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Good
Kong
Memoirs
Star Wars
Munich
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
War
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Our Time
James (Film Report)
67% (12/18)
67% (12/18)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Munich
Memoirs
Crash
-
-
-
-
-
-
Jeffrey Wells (Hollywood Elsewhere)
71% (17/24)
81% (17/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
War
Death
Penguins
Badgered
Our Time
Joan Vadeboncoer (Post-Standard)
80% (4/5)
80% (4/5)
80% (4/5)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Jonathan Alba (The Oscar Igloo)
65% (15/23)
75% (15/20)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Hustle
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
-
Our Time
Joshua Lawson (Oscar Talk)
67% (16/24)
76% (16/21)
63% (5/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Williams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Ken Tucker (Entertainment Weekly)
67% (16/24)
62% (13/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Good
Memoirs
Narnia
Henderson
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
Memoirs
Triumph
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
Kevyn Knox (The Cinematheque)
54% (13/24)
62% (13/21)
63% (5/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Williams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Kirk Honeycutt (Hollywood Reporter)
50% (5/10)
50% (5/10)
67% (4/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
-
-
Squid
Brokeback
Lee
Corpse
-
Good
Kong
-
Memoirs
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Kris Tapley (In Contention)
75% (18/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Kristin Veitch (E!)
17% (1/6)
17% (1/6)
17% (1/6)
 
Brokeback
Howard
Huffman
Clooney
Williams
-
-
Haggis
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Mark Bakalor (Oscar Central)
79% (19/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
Source
All
Top 21
Top 8
 
Picture
Actor
Actress
S. Actor
S. Actress
Orig. Screenpl.
Adapt. Screenpl.
Director
Anim. Feat.
Foreign
Cinematog.
Art Dir.
Vis. Effects
Costume
Make-Up
Editing
Score
Song
Sound
Sound Edit.
Doc. Short
Doc. Feature
Anim. Short
Live Action Short
Michael Sragow (Baltimore Sun)
63% (15/24)
71% (15/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Joyeux
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Constant
Brokeback
Hustle
Memoirs
Memoirs
Rwanda
Penguins
9
Farm
Michael Phillips (Chicago Tribune)
75% (18/24)
76% (16/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Murderball
Moon
Shooter
Mike Clark (USA Today)
50% (3/6)
50% (3/6)
50% (3/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Williams
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Nathaniel Rogers (Film Experience)
71% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Odds Checker
67% (14/21)
74% (14/19)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
-
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
-
Memoirs
Transamerica
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
-
Odie (Cinemaniac)
71% (17/24)
71% (15/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Star Wars
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
War
Triumph
Penguins
9
Shooter
Oscar Jam
55% (11/20)
55% (11/20)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Williams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Kong
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Constant
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
Kong
-
-
-
-
Oscar Tracker (USA Today)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Oscar Watch
75% (18/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
9
Shooter
Pat Pemberton (Tribune News)
33% (2/6)
33% (2/6)
33% (2/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Huffman
Gylenhaal
Keener
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Pete Hammond (Maxim)
75% (18/24)
86% (18/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Hustle
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Our Time
Peter Howell (Toronto Star)
75% (18/24)
76% (16/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Good
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
Peter Travers (Rolling Stone)
71% (17/24)
81% (17/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Pinnacle Sports Odds
75% (3/4)
75% (3/4)
75% (3/4)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
-
-
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Q (Academy Award Speculation)
67% (16/24)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Walk
Kong
Death
Penguins
One
Our Time
Reuben Pereira (Beacon Newspaper)
88% (7/8)
88% (7/8)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Richard Propes (Independent Critics)
29% (7/24)
29% (7/24)
63% (5/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Adams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Corpse
Paradise
Brokeback
Good
Narnia
Memoirs
Narnia
Cinderella
Munich
Transamerica
Walk
Memoirs
Rwanda
Murderball
9
Our Time
Robert Butler (Kansas City Star)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
83% (5/6)
 
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Robert Licuria (Awards Heaven)
67% (14/21)
67% (14/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Gylenhaal
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Memoirs
Kong
Kong
Memoirs
Star Wars
Constant
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
Robert Schuette (Film Frenzy)
90% (19/21)
90% (19/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
Source
All
Top 21
Top 8
 
Picture
Actor
Actress
S. Actor
S. Actress
Orig. Screenpl.
Adapt. Screenpl.
Director
Anim. Feat.
Foreign
Cinematog.
Art Dir.
Vis. Effects
Costume
Make-Up
Editing
Score
Song
Sound
Sound Edit.
Doc. Short
Doc. Feature
Anim. Short
Live Action Short
Richard Roeper (Chicago Sun Times)
89% (17/19)
89% (17/19)
100% (8/8)
 
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
-
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
-
-
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
-
Penguins
-
Cashback
Roger Ebert (Chicago Sun Times)
71% (15/21)
71% (15/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Crash
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Adams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Good
Kong
Kong
Pride
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Narnia
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
Ron (Film-Otaku)
71% (15/21)
71% (15/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Crash
Ledger
Witherspoon
Clooney
Williams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Hustle
Walk
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
Russ (And the Oscar Goes To...)
71% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Walk
Kong
Triumph
Penguins
Jasper
Cashback
Sarah Linn (The Tribune News)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
60% (3/5)
 
Brokeback
Pheonix
Witherspoon
Clooney
Williams
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Sasha Stone (Oscar Watch)
58% (14/24)
67% (14/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Runaway
Scott Bowles (USA Today)
65% (15/23)
67% (14/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Memoirs
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Cinderella
Constant
Brokeback
-
Walk
War
Rwanda
Penguins
One
Shooter
Scott Feinberg (and the winner is...)
88% (21/24)
86% (18/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Kong
Kong
Triumph
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
Sean Leary (Quad Cities Online)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Adams
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Shane McNeil (Oscar Talk)
79% (17/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
9
Runaway
Shawn (Oscar Sights)
67% (16/24)
71% (15/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Gylenhaal
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Transamerica
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Spencer Shannon (Oscar Talk)
79% (17/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
Death
Penguins
9
Runaway
Steve Pond (Oscar Beat)
75% (18/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Memoirs
Crash
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Jasper
Shooter
TC Candler (Independent Critics)
33% (8/24)
33% (8/24)
63% (5/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Dillon
Adams
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Paradise
Brokeback
Good
War
Memoirs
Narnia
Munich
Pride
Crash
War
War
Rwanda
Enron
One
Cashback
Ted Casablanca (E!)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Huffman
Clooney
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Terry Lawson (Detroit Free Press)
67% (14/21)
67% (14/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Good
Kong
Memoirs
Star Wars
Crash
Munich
Transamerica
Kong
Kong
-
Penguins
-
-
Thelma Adams (US Weekly)
79% (19/24)
81% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Batman
Memoirs
Narnia
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Crash
Kong
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Shooter
Tim Lammers (NBC4, Washington DC)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
67% (4/6)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Giamatti
Weisz
-
-
Lee
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
-
Tom O'Neil (Gold Derby)
79% (17/24)
76% (16/21)
75% (6/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Huffman
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Sophie
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Hustle
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Runaway
Wesley Lovell (The Oscar Guy)
75% (18/24)
% (17/21)
88% (7/8)
 
Brokeback
Hoffman
Witherspoon
Clooney
Weisz
Crash
Brokeback
Lee
Wallace
Tsotsi
Brokeback
Memoirs
Kong
Memoirs
Narnia
Crash
Brokeback
Transamerica
Walk
Kong
Rwanda
Penguins
Moon
Our Time
% Correct Averages -->
68%
72%
76%
7%
95%
92%
60%
78%
97%
99%
98%
97%
58%
12%
83%
91%
95%
86%
77%
53%
25%
45%
82%
9%
90%
36%
33%
Source
All
Top 21
Top 8
 
Picture
Actor
Actress
S. Actor
S. Actress
Orig. Screenpl.
Adapt. Screenpl.
Director
Anim. Feat.
Foreign
Cinematog.
Art Dir.
Vis. Effects
Costume
Make-Up
Editing
Score
Song
Sound
Sound Edit.
Doc. Short
Doc. Feature
Anim. Short
Live Action Short